Pros and Cons of Peel and Stick Tile vs. Traditional Tile: Which One is Right for You?

Dec 05, 2023

Are you considering installing new tiles in your home but unsure whether to choose peel-and-stick tiles or traditional tiles? You're not alone. With so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which type of tile is best suited for your needs. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of peel and stick tile and traditional tile, providing you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Understanding Sticky Tile

Peel and stick tiles, also known as sticky tiles, are a popular choice for homeowners seeking a quick and easy installation process.

These tiles are made from a premium synthetic material that is durable and resistant to water damage.

The installation process is simple and can be completed as a DIY project. All you need to do is peel off the backing and stick the tiles onto the desired surface.


Black and Gold Hexagon Tile and Bathroom
Copper Picket Tile for Bathroom

Pros of Sticky Tile

1. Easy Installation

Peel and stick tiles are a fantastic option for anyone looking for a fast and hassle-free installation process. No mess, no stress, just a quick and easy DIY project. And we tell you, they aren't called peel and stick for nothing. Installation is as easy as removing the protective backing and pressing the tile onto the desired surface. It really is that simple!

Take for example our 10-pack Copper Picket 12 in. x 12 in. Honed Metal Peel and Stick Backsplash Tile for Kitchen and Bathroom used in the bathroom wall above. The installation process was a total breeze.

Seriously, it was so easy that the homeowner had these faux tiles up on the wall in no time. And the best part? The end result is absolute perfection.

The copper finish adds a touch of elegance and sophistication to the bathroom. It gives off a warm and inviting vibe that just makes you want to spend all day in there (okay, maybe not all day, but you get the point!).

2. Affordable

Let's get down to the really exciting thing about peel-and-stick tiles: the cost. Sticky tiles are generally more affordable than traditional tiles, a true blessing for the frugalistas out there.

These wallet-friendly wonders come at a fraction of the cost of traditional tiles so if you're on a budget, peel-and-stick tiles provide a cost-effective solution.

Just take a look at this stunning bathroom. It's oozing with elegance and sophistication like it's nobody's business, right? But guess what? The magic ingredient behind this jaw-dropping bathroom sink is our White and Gold Stack in Metal Peel and Stick Backsplash Tile.

The peel and stick tiles were able to make this space look like a marvelous work of art without costing an arm and a leg.

White and Gold Metal Peel and Stick Tile
Silver Hexagon Mix Tile

3. Versatile

Sticky tiles offer a wide variety of options to suit every taste and design aesthetic, allowing you to find the perfect match for your home decor.

They can mimic the appearance of natural stone or other materials, giving you a wide range of design options.

No matter if you're into classic marble, funky geometric patterns, or trendy wood-look tiles, there's a peel and stick design waiting to blow your mind.

4. Removable

One of the significant advantages of sticky tiles is that they can be easily removed without causing damage to the surface. Talk about flexibility!

So if you're renting or just looking for a temporary design solution, peel-and-stick tiles like our very own White and Gold Hexagon Metal Peel and Stick Backsplash Tile will surely make an excellent option.

You can easily remove these tiles without leaving a trace. Feel free to change up your style whenever you want without facing the wrath of your landlord or your own boredom.

Metal Peel and Stick Backsplash Tile
White Carrara Hexagon Tile

Cons of Sticky Tile

1. Durability

Most peel-and-stick tiles are designed to handle humid environments and occasional splashes. But when it comes to a full-on war with water, they might not emerge victorious. Over time, the adhesive may weaken, causing the tiles to buckle or become loose.

Another main concern lies in those spaces where one tile meets another tile. You see, peel-and-stick tiles don't require the use of grout or a cement backer board to stay in place, which is awesome for easy installation.

However, it does leave a tiny vulnerable space for potential water infiltration. And we all know that water finding its way can lead to problems.

2. Not as High-Quality

Here's the deal: peel and stick tiles are like the chameleons of the design world. They can mimic the look of natural stone, and from a distance, they can fool even the wisest of design experts. But upon closer inspection, you might notice a slight compromise. Yep, we're talking about texture and depth.

Traditional tiles often boast a luxurious depth and texture that can make a space truly shine. The subtle variations in the surface and the feel under your fingertips can elevate the overall aesthetic to a whole new level. But unfortunately, peel-and-stick tiles might not offer the same level of pizzazz.

White and Silver Stack Peel and Stick Tile
Gold Hexagon Honed Metal Peel and Stick Tile

3. Limited Application

Sticky tiles are best suited for dry, non-porous surfaces. However, when it comes to uneven or textured surfaces, they might not adhere as well as we would hope.

If you're hoping to revamp that rustic, textured wall with peel-and-stick tile, you might want to reconsider your options.

Now, what exactly do we mean by "uneven surfaces"? Think about walls with heavy texture or floors with pronounced dips or bumps.

Unfortunately, peel-and-stick tiles are not designed to easily conform to these uneven surfaces. They might not adhere properly and could end up looking less than flawless. Nobody wants the hassle of tiles that start peeling off or looking uneven after the hard work you've put into your project.

Exploring Traditional Tile

Traditional tiles, such as ceramic tiles, have long been a popular choice for homeowners. These tiles are made from clay and other natural materials, providing a timeless and elegant look. The installation process for traditional tiles is more involved and typically requires professional assistance.

Blue and Gray Herringbone Tile
White 8 in. x 8 in. Polished Marble Mosaic Tile

Pros of Traditional Tile

1. High-Quality Appearance

While peel and stick tiles may be convenient, there's just no match for the elegant sophistication that traditional tiles bring to the table.

The range of styles, colors, and textures available allows you to design a space that is uniquely you, while adding value to your home. Plus with options for high-quality materials like marble and porcelain, you can achieve a stunning and classy look that will take your breath away.

Take a moment to appreciate our White Polished Marble Mosaic Tile in action on this thoughtfully designed bathroom floor.

The white polished marble mosaic tile on the floor creates a light and airy vibe while adding that high-quality finish that says "impeccable style and class". You can practically feel the coolness of the marble underfoot and the overall effect is breathtaking. It's safe to say that traditional tiles will take your home decor game to the next level.

2. Long-Lasting

When installed correctly, traditional tiles have the power to stand their ground for longer than we can count. Water damage? Splash away in the shower, spill your morning coffee (it happens), or even create an indoor water park (well, maybe not), and your traditional tiles will just laugh it off.

Worrying about wear and tear? No problem here! Traditional tiles are built to last, enduring the trials and tribulations of everyday life while keeping your walls and floors looking fab for years to come.

There's no doubt that these ones are an excellent long-term investment.

Cerulean Blue 3 in. x 6 in. Polished Glass Mosaic Tile
Black 12 in. x 12 in. Penny Round Polished Glass Mosaic Tile

3. Wide Range of Applications

One of the greatest benefits of using traditional tiles is their versatility. These tiles are suitable for various areas of the home, including bathrooms, kitchens, and living spaces. Whether you want to give your bathroom a fresh new look or revamp your kitchen, traditional tiles can do the trick. They have the power to add a touch of opulence and charm to any room.

Another plus point is that traditional tiles don't just work their magic on walls and floors - they can also wrap around unique-shaped objects, such as columns and arched spaces.

This means you can bring a touch of creativity to your home by incorporating tiles in unexpected areas. Just imagine how stylish and eye-catching it would be to have a column covered in charming penny tiles!

Cons of Traditional Tile

1. Higher Cost

Traditional tiles tend to be pricier than their peel-and-stick counterparts. From the cost of the tile themselves, to the installation process, it all adds up, making it a significantly expensive investment.

For those who are on a budget, this might not be the best option. However, if you are willing to invest in the long run, traditional tiles can make for a great addition to your home.

Blue Polished and Matte Finished Glass Mosaic Tile
Brown 11.8 in. x 11.8 in. Polished Glass Mosaic Tile

2. Complex Installation

Installing traditional tiles requires a bit more skill and expertise than just slapping sticky tiles on the wall. It involves using mortar and grout, a process that can be messy and time-consuming.

If you're new to traditional tiles, we highly recommend seeking professional assistance. This is especially important if you're a beginner or have never installed tiles before. A professional will ensure that your tiles are installed correctly, and there will be no issues with your newly renovated space down the line.

3. Challenging to Replace

When a traditional tile cracks, it's not as simple as just popping in a new one like you would with a piece of a jigsaw puzzle. Nope, unfortunately, it's a bit more complicated.

Traditional tiles are often tightly joined (check out the photo above for reference), which means the surrounding tiles may need to be removed to properly replace the damaged one. And sometimes, the situation can be a bit more difficult to resolve.

In some instances, it may be necessary to remove a larger section of the tiles to ensure a seamless replacement. Worst, the entire area may require retiling.

Gray 12 in. x 12 in. Square Polished Marble Mosaic Tile

Making the Right Choice for You

Now that we've explored the pros and cons of peel and stick tile and traditional tile, you may be wondering which option is best for you. The answer depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. Here are a few factors to consider:

  • Budget: : If you're on a tight budget and looking for a cost-effective solution, sticky tiles may be the better choice. They are generally more affordable and offer a wide range of design options.
  • Durability : If you're looking for long-lasting tiles that can withstand heavy foot traffic and moisture, traditional tiles are the better option. They are known for their durability and longevity.
  • Installation : : If you're a DIY enthusiast and enjoy tackling home improvement projects, sticky tiles may be a suitable option. They are easy to install and require minimal tools and skills. However, if you prefer a professional installation or have complex design requirements, traditional tiles may be the better choice.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: Consider the look you want to achieve in your space. Sticky tiles offer versatility and can mimic the appearance of natural stone or other materials. Traditional tiles, on the other hand, provide a high-quality and timeless look that adds value to your home.

Ultimately, the choice between peel-and-stick tile and traditional tile depends on your personal preferences, budget, and the specific requirements of your project. Take the time to weigh the pros and cons and consider consulting with a tile specialist or contractor for expert advice.

With so many options available on the market today, it can be difficult to make a decision. However, with careful research and consideration, you can find the perfect tile solution for your home! And remember, whether you opt for sticky tile or traditional tile, both options can absolutely enhance the beauty and functionality of your space. Need some help? Chat with Apollo Tile Pros today!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.